In the world of cinema, there are films that push the boundaries of what we consider acceptable or palatable. The Substance, the latest offering from French director Coralie Fargeat, is one such cinematic experience. This visceral and uncompromising body horror drama delves into the depths of societal pressures, the tyranny of beauty standards, and the devastating impact they can have on a woman’s psyche.
At the heart of this film is the captivating performance of Demi Moore, who takes on the role of Elizabeth Sparkel, a former Hollywood starlet struggling to maintain relevance in a youth-obsessed industry. Moore’s portrayal is a tour de force, as she navigates the complex emotional landscape of a woman grappling with the harsh realities of aging and the relentless pursuit of physical perfection.
The Descent into Despair
The film opens with a brilliant sequence that sets the tone for the journey ahead. We witness the installation of Elizabeth’s star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame, a moment of triumph and adoration that quickly gives way to the harsh realities of her fading career. As the years pass, we see Elizabeth’s star become tarnished and forgotten, mirroring the deterioration of her own self-worth and public image.
This downward spiral is further exacerbated when Elizabeth overhears the callous and derogatory remarks of a television executive, played with delicious malice by Dennis Quaid. The sting of these words cuts deep, shattering Elizabeth’s fragile sense of self and sending her on a desperate quest to reclaim her former glory.
What follows is a harrowing descent into the depths of Elizabeth’s despair, as she becomes consumed by a relentless pursuit of physical transformation. Fargeat’s direction is masterful, using the camera to capture the visceral and unsettling nature of Elizabeth’s journey. The close-up shots and distorted angles create a sense of unease, mirroring the turmoil within the character.
The Substance: A Twisted Panacea
At the heart of this narrative is the titular “substance,” a mysterious and illicit concoction that promises to restore Elizabeth’s youthful appearance. The introduction of this element is where the film truly takes a turn into the realm of body horror, as Fargeat delves into the grotesque and the unspeakable.
The process of administering the substance is a harrowing and unforgettable sequence, as Elizabeth undergoes a transformation that is both visually stunning and deeply unsettling.
Fargeat’s use of sound design and editing amplifies the sensory assault, creating an immersive and overwhelming experience for the viewer.
The transformation itself is a masterclass in practical effects, with the film’s team delivering a truly remarkable and disturbing visual spectacle.
But the substance is not merely a physical transformation; it represents a deeper, more insidious change within Elizabeth. As she becomes consumed by the promise of youthful perfection, the line between her old self and her new “ideal” self begins to blur, leading to a chilling exploration of identity and self-acceptance.
The Tyranny of Beauty Standards
At its core, The Substance is a scathing commentary on the tyranny of beauty standards and the devastating impact they can have on a woman’s sense of self-worth. Fargeat’s script delves into the misogyny and ageism that permeate the entertainment industry, as well as the internalized self-loathing that many women experience in the face of these relentless societal pressures.
The character of Elizabeth Sparkel is a powerful representation of this struggle. As a former Hollywood darling, she has been conditioned to believe that her value is intrinsically tied to her physical appearance. The film’s exploration of her descent into self-hatred and desperation is both heartbreaking and infuriating, a stark reminder of the toll that these unrealistic expectations can take on a person’s psyche.
Fargeat’s decision to cast Demi Moore in this role is a stroke of genius, as the actress’s own experiences with the industry’s obsession with youth and beauty lend an added layer of authenticity to the performance. Moore’s ability to convey the raw emotion and vulnerability of Elizabeth’s journey is truly remarkable, and it is a testament to her skill as an actress.
The Emergence of the “Sue”
As Elizabeth’s transformation progresses, the film introduces the character of “Sue,” a mysterious and enigmatic figure who becomes inextricably linked to Elizabeth’s journey. Played with chilling intensity by Margaret Qualley, Sue represents the embodiment of the societal ideals that Elizabeth is desperately trying to attain.
Sue’s introduction is marked by a series of unsettling scenes, where the camera lingers on the intricate details of her body during a fitness routine, reducing her to a collection of desirable parts rather than a whole person.
This objectification is a deliberate choice by Fargeat, who uses the camera to mirror the way in which society often views and commodifies the female form.
Qualley’s performance as Sue is a masterclass in physical acting, as she seamlessly transitions between the character’s outward confidence and the underlying darkness that lurks beneath the surface.
The relationship between Elizabeth and Sue is a complex and layered one, as the two women become inextricably linked in a twisted dance of self-destruction and self-discovery. The film’s exploration of this dynamic is a powerful commentary on the ways in which women are often pitted against one another in the pursuit of societal approval, and the devastating consequences that can arise from this toxic dynamic.
The Extremes of “Cinema Extreme”
One of the most striking aspects of The Substance is its place within the broader context of the “Cinema Extreme” movement, a French cinematic tradition that has long been dominated by male filmmakers. Fargeat’s entry into this arena is a bold and subversive act, as she reclaims the genre and imbues it with a distinctly feminine perspective.
The film’s visual style is a testament to Fargeat’s directorial prowess, as she employs a range of techniques to create a truly immersive and unsettling experience. The use of macros, distorted angles, and a vibrant color palette evoke the work of Stanley Kubrick, particularly in his seminal film A Clockwork Orange.
But Fargeat’s approach is not merely an homage; it is a deliberate subversion of the genre’s traditional tropes. By centering the female experience and exploring the complexities of Elizabeth’s journey, Fargeat challenges the male gaze that has long been a hallmark of the “Cinema Extreme” movement. The result is a film that is both visually stunning and emotionally devastating, a powerful statement on the ways in which women are often objectified and dehumanized in the pursuit of societal ideals.
The Divisive Ending
The final act of The Substance has been the subject of much debate and discussion, with some viewers finding the film’s conclusion to be a departure from the tightly-controlled and unsettling tone that Fargeat had established up to that point.
In the film’s final 20 minutes, the narrative takes a turn towards the surreal and the fantastical, as Elizabeth’s transformation reaches its climactic conclusion. For some, this shift in tone and style feels jarring and out of place, disrupting the carefully crafted sense of unease that had permeated the film’s earlier scenes.
However, others have argued that this shift is a deliberate and necessary choice, as it represents the ultimate manifestation of Elizabeth’s descent into madness and self-loathing. The film’s conclusion, with its visceral and unsettling imagery, is a powerful statement on the consequences of the relentless pursuit of physical perfection, and the ways in which it can ultimately consume and destroy the individual.
Regardless of one’s opinion on the film’s ending, it is clear that The Substance is a bold and uncompromising work of cinema that challenges the viewer to confront the darker aspects of the human experience. Fargeat’s direction, combined with the powerful performances of Demi Moore and Margaret Qualley, make this film a must-see for fans of challenging and thought-provoking cinema.
Conclusion
In the end, The Substance is a film that will linger in the mind long after the credits have rolled. It is a visceral and uncompromising exploration of the societal pressures that women face, and the devastating impact they can have on one’s sense of self-worth and identity.
Demi Moore’s performance is a tour de force, as she navigates the complex emotional landscape of a woman grappling with the harsh realities of aging and the relentless pursuit of physical perfection. Coralie Fargeat’s direction is a masterclass in cinematic storytelling, as she employs a range of techniques to create a truly immersive and unsettling experience.
Whether you find the film’s conclusion to be a bold and necessary choice or a departure from the tightly-controlled tone that had come before, The Substance is a film that demands to be seen and discussed. It is a powerful and uncompromising work of cinema that challenges the viewer to confront the darker aspects of the human experience, and to consider the ways in which we as a society perpetuate the tyranny of beauty standards.
For more insights and reviews on The Substance and other recent films, be sure to follow me on my various social media platforms:
About the Author
